The levels of sedation
The American Society of Anesthesiologists describes sedation and anesthesia as a continuum. Each level is defined by how a person responds and how well they breathe on their own.E2Good1
| Level | What the ASA definition says |
|---|---|
| Minimal sedation | People respond normally to spoken commands. Thinking and coordination may be impaired, but airway reflexes, breathing and circulation are unaffected.E2Good1 |
| Moderate sedation (conscious sedation) | People respond purposefully to spoken commands, alone or with a light touch. No help is needed to keep the airway open, breathing is adequate, and circulation is usually maintained.E2Good4 |
| Deep sedation | People cannot be easily woken but respond purposefully to repeated or painful stimulation. Breathing on their own may be impaired, and they may need help keeping the airway open.E2Good1 |
| General anesthesia | A drug-induced loss of consciousness in which people cannot be woken, even by painful stimulation. The ability to breathe independently is often impaired.E2Good1 |
Sedation can become deeper than intended. For this reason, the ASA says whoever gives moderate sedation should be able to rescue a person who slips into deep sedation. Likewise, whoever gives deep sedation should be able to rescue a person who slips into general anesthesia.E2Good4
What is monitored anesthesia care (MAC)?
The ASA explains that monitored anesthesia care is not a level on the continuum. It is a specific anesthesia service performed by a qualified anesthesia provider for a diagnostic or therapeutic procedure.E2Good4
The propofol label lists starting and maintaining MAC sedation in adults among its uses. It says that for general anesthesia or MAC sedation it should be given only by people trained in general anesthesia who are not doing the procedure.Official text5
A study of malpractice claims found that oversedation leading to slowed breathing was an important cause of injury during MAC. It also found that monitoring, vigilance and early resuscitation could have prevented many of these injuries.E2Good6
More than 40% of the MAC claims involved death or permanent brain damage, similar to claims for general anesthesia.E2Good6
Spinal, epidural and nerve block anesthesia
An epidural is a central nerve block: local anesthetic is injected close to the nerves that carry pain.E1Strong7
Spinal and epidural anesthesia together are called neuraxial blockade. An overview of randomized trials found overall deaths about a third lower in patients assigned to neuraxial blockade.E1Strong8
The authors said the size of some of these benefits is uncertain. They said more research is needed to know whether they come from the block itself or partly from avoiding general anesthesia.E1Strong8
In the REGAIN trial of older adults having hip fracture surgery, spinal anesthesia was not superior to general anesthesia for survival and walking at 60 days. Delirium rates were similar.E1Strong3
A UK national audit found serious complications of spinal and epidural anesthesia rare. Permanent injury was estimated at 2.0 to 4.2 per 100,000 cases, and two thirds of initially disabling injuries resolved fully.E2Good2
A review estimated neurological complications after spinal or epidural blocks at under 0.04%. It estimated nerve symptoms after peripheral nerve blocks at under 3%, with permanent injury rare.Review9
Who gives anesthesia?
The propofol label covers who gives it for general anesthesia or MAC sedation. It states it should be given only by people trained in general anesthesia who are not involved in the procedure itself. The sevoflurane label says the same for that gas.Official text5,10
What is not known yet
Whether the benefits seen with neuraxial anesthesia come from the block itself or partly from avoiding general anesthesia is still uncertain.E1Strong8
Questions you might bring to your anesthesia team
- What type and depth of anesthesia is planned, and why?
- Who will give the anesthesia, and who will watch my breathing throughout?
- Is a spinal, epidural or nerve block an option for this procedure?
- What are the common side effects and the rare serious risks of the plan?